Carrot Top Pastries Menu (Update 2025)

**Introducing the Menu at Carrot Top Pastries**

Located in the heart of New York City, Carrot Top Pastries offers a delightful array of baked goods and savory dishes. The menu showcases daily specials like Vegetable Lasagna, Crab Cakes on a Hero, and Turkey Burger, ensuring a variety of options for every palate.

Customers rave about the famous Carrot Cake and other pastries, highlighting the perfect balance of moistness and sweetness. The buttercream frosting on the carrot cake is not overly sweet, making it a standout item.

Aside from the sweet treats, the menu also features hot sandwiches platters like Chicken Cutlet Parm and Grilled Chicken Caesar Hero, providing savory options for a satisfying meal.

Overall, Carrot Top Pastries is a cozy spot with excellent customer service and a reputation for serving the best carrot muffins and cakes in the area. Visit this bakery for a delicious culinary experience that will leave you craving more.

Daily Specials

Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salad

$12.98

Chicken Strips with Roasted Potatoes

$11.21

Crispy Chicken Caesar Salad

$12.98

Vegetable Lasagna

$11.50

Meat Lasagna

$12.09

Baked Ziti

$10.91

Baked Zit with Meatball

$12.68

Baked Ziti with Chicken

$12.68

Stuffed Shells

$10.91

Crab Cakes On a Hero

$12.68

Veggie Burger On a Hero

$12.09

Cheese Steak

$13.27

Pepper Steak on a Hero

$12.68

Turkey Burger

$12.39

Hamburger on a Hero

$12.39

Cheeseburger on a Hero

$12.98

Crispy Chicken Hero

$11.50

Chicken Cutlet Parm

$11.21

Eggplant Parm

$11.21

Meatball Parm

$11.21

Sausage and Peppers

$10.91

Grilled Chicken Caesar Hero

$11.50

Chicken Fingers

$10.32

Hot Sandwiches Platters

Soups

Soup of the Day

$5.31

French Onion Soup

$5.90

Chef's Salad

Your choice of 2 Deli meats and 2 cheese.

$11.80

Tossed Salad

$9.44

Pasta Salad

$10.62

Caesar Salad

$8.50

Salads

Side Orders

French Fries

$5.90

Onion Rings

$5.90

Home Fries

$4.72

American

$0.50

Provolone Swiss

$0.50

Pepp Jack

$0.50

Cheddar

$0.50

Mozzarella

$0.50

Cheeses

Dressings

Creamy Italian

$0.50

French Russian

$0.50

Oil and Vinegar

$0.50

Caesar Balsamic and Ranch

$0.50

Egg on A Roll

Comes with bacon, sausage or your choice of deli meat for an additional charge.

$4.72

Eggs Fries and Toast

$7.67

French Toast

$7.37

Pancakes

$9.44

Potato and Egg on a Hero

You may add extra topping for an additional price.

$8.55

Breakfast Menu

Omelettes

Cheese Omelet

$8.26

Viggie Omelet

Vegan.

$8.26

Western Omelet

$9.44

Carrot Muffins

$3.24

Corn Muffins

$3.24

Blueberry

$3.24

Cocolate Chip Muffins

$3.24

Cheese Danish

$3.24

Pecan Danish

$3.24

Croissant

$3.24

Assorted Pastries

Deli Sandwiches

Turkey Breast

$9.38

Cracked Pepper Turkey

$9.38

Pastrami

$9.73

Salad Club

$8.75

Corned Beef

$9.44

Chicken Club

$10.91

Ham and cheese

$9.38

Salami and Cheese

$9.38

Tuna Salad

$9.38

Chicken Salad

$9.02

Egg Salad

$9.02

Bacon Lettuce and Tomato

$9.02

Turkey Club

$10.03

Italian Hoagie

$10.91